Quick Colts Neck NJ MLS Search

Browse All Colts Neck NJ Waterfront Properties for Sale

$3,695,000
4 Beds 5 Baths
There is only one property in Colts Neck that offers direct, cleared waterfront access to the Swimming River Reservoir; and this is it. 57 Beaver Dam Road is not simply a home; it is a once-in-a-generation estate where meticulous renovation, uncompromising craftsmanship, and an outdoor sanctuary unlike anything else on the market converge on 1.27 breathtaking acres with nearly 350 feet of water frontage. This is waterfront living, redefined. Reimagined and expertly expanded in 2019-2020, this 4-bedroom, 4-full and 1-half-bath Colonial boasts a total of nearly 6,000 square feet of living space, of extraordinary craftsmanship seen in every corner. A dramatic double-height foyer welcomes you into a home where no detail was left unconsidered. The main level unfolds with effortless elegance: two distinct living spaces, a private office, a first-floor primary suite, and a stunning kitchen renovation completed in 2025, fully appointed for the most discerning of chefs and entertainers. Multiple points of access lead you directly to the resplendent backyard and sweeping, unobstructed views of the Swimming River Reservoir. A recessed bar offers panoramic vistas of the property, designed for effortless entertaining at any scale. Descend to the full basement, where a fully enclosed, temperature-controlled wine room awaits, capable of housing hundreds of bottles for the true connoisseur. A full bath, generous space for a home gym or private retreat, and direct access to the garage complete this level. Upstairs, two generously proportioned bedrooms share a beautifully appointed full bath, while a secondary suite offers its own private ensuite. Words scarcely do justice to this outdoor masterpiece, crafted by the renowned Millennium Stoneworks. Two tiers of decking set the stage for an entertainer's paradise, anchored by multiple fire pits, integrated outdoor lighting, and surround sound spread throughout the grounds. The outdoor kitchen is nothing short of world-class, equipped with a teppanyaki grill, Chicago Brick Oven, Alfresco grill and burners, refrigeration, ice storage, and so much more all crowned in leathered granite countertops beneath a motorized pergola built for effortless, all-season enjoyment. The pool deck and entertaining area are finished in oversized, imported Italian porcelain tile, guiding you past yet another fire pit overlooking the property to a custom cabana featuring an 8 person+ Caldera spa, a 6ft wide Montego gas fireplace, misting fans, Bromic heaters, integrated speakers, and more! The cabana doubles as a striking diving platform into the deep end of the heated pool, with a depth of ~10 feet. Set on 1.27 pristine acres with nearly 350 feet of combined water frontage; the only property of its kind offering cleared, direct, and walk-in access to the Swimming River Reservoir. 57 Beaver Dam Road is a genuinely irreplaceable offering. Just minutes from downtown Lincroft, Lifetime Fitness, and the area's finest shopping and dining, this estate delivers the rare combination of total privacy, natural beauty, and everyday convenience. For the buyer who demands nothing less than extraordinary, 57 Beaver Dam Road isn't just a home, it's a legacy.

57 Beaver Dam Road, Colts Neck

Listing courtesy of Serhant New Jersey LLC. Contact:

$7,499,910
7 Beds 11 Baths
Windy Hill Farm. The name says everything. Perched atop 38 breathtaking acres on iconic Montrose Road -- flanked on three sides by preserved farmland and surrounded by some of the area's most notable private estates -- this hand-crafted limestone manor is Colts Neck at its most extraordinary. A quarter-mile London plane-lined drive builds anticipation before the house even appears. Inside, a top-to-bottom transformation: refinished French roasted oak floors, fully remodeled kitchen, new countertops, refreshed first-floor baths, and all-new light fixtures throughout. Amish-built equipment barn. 14-stall horse barn. Private pond. 200-tree orchard. Home furnishings negotiable. 12 miles to the beach. 1 hour to NYC. This is the one. There are properties that photograph beautifully. And then there are properties that change you the moment you arrive. Windy Hill Farm is the latter. The approach alone is an event. Stone stanchions mark the entrance -- gate infrastructure already in place should the next owner desire them. From there, a quarter-mile paved drive lined with London Plain trees unfolds like a country lane, the kind that makes you slow down instinctively. The farmland to the left, right, and behind is permanently preserved. That is not a detail -- it is a guarantee. The privacy, the views, the silence: protected forever. And the neighbors? Some of the most notable private estates in all of Monmouth County flank this property -- a corridor that serious buyers will immediately recognize. The house materializes from behind the trees and immediately communicates something that cannot be manufactured: permanence. Four sides of solid Pennsylvania limestone -- not veneer -- each piece hand-chiseled over the course of two years. A variegated Vermont slate roof that graduates in thickness from top to bottom. Old Carolina brick accents around every window and door, each brick hand-molded in cast. Custom Marvin windows and doors throughout. This exterior took years to build and cannot be replicated at any price. Inside, the home has just undergone a comprehensive refresh that makes it entirely move-in ready while preserving every element that makes it irreplaceable. French roasted oak floors -- kiln-dried like a wine barrel to eliminate expansion and contraction -- have been refinished throughout. The kitchen has been fully remodeled with new countertops and refaced cabinetry, anchored by a Wolf six-burner range with griddle, twin Sub-Zeros, two Miele dishwashers, and a Shaw farmhouse sink. First-floor bathrooms have been remodeled. Every light fixture in the home has been replaced. The entire interior has been repainted. Nothing has been left for the next owner to address. The rooms themselves tell the story of a builder who spared nothing. The hunting room features a 30-foot wood-burning fireplace clad in real stone, quarter-sawn oak paneling, Ralph Lauren suede paint, and an alabaster chandelier on a winch. Barn beams reclaimed from a Wisconsin dairy farm anchor the dining room ceiling. A custom Chesney's of London fireplace. Built-ins with antique mirrors and leaded glass. A butler's pantry with built-in Miele coffee maker plumbed directly to a water line. These are not finishes -- they are chapters. The primary suite occupies its own wing: his-and-hers bathrooms with steam shower, whirlpool tub, and radiant floors; his-and-hers walk-in closets; a gas fireplace; a private deck with custom wrought iron railing. Three additional bedrooms each have en-suite baths. A second-floor laundry room. A walk-in linen closet. A sitting room. The home functions as effortlessly as it impresses. A private apartment with its own entrance via the garage -- lockable from inside the main house -- provides ideal accommodation for live-in staff or extended family. The attic houses a commercial-grade gym, a massage and yoga studio with half bath, and air conditioning. The basement offers room for a media room, stage, craft room, and abundant storage. A four-car garage with radiant heated floors and a dog shower with hot water completes the picture. Outside, 38 acres unfold into a private world. A pond. An orchard of over 200 apple, peach, and cherry trees. Multiple paddocks and run-ins with water accessible throughout. A 14-stall horse barn, fully refurbished with a half bath. An Amish hand-built equipment barn. Bluestone patios. An outdoor wood-burning fireplace flanked by gas Bevolo lanterns. 33 of the 38 acres carry farm assessment -- renewed annually -- delivering significant tax relief that sophisticated buyers will recognize immediately. Home furnishings are available for negotiation, separate from the listing price -- a rare opportunity to acquire a property of this caliber fully appointed and truly turnkey. Twelve miles to the beach. Fifteen minutes to Red Bank and Asbury Park. One hour to Manhattan. Three sides of preserved farmland. Notable private estates on all sides. Thirty-eight acres. One opportunity. Who knows when this magnificent estate will be available again.

88 Montrose Road, Colts Neck

Listing courtesy of Prive Haus LLC. Contact:

$1,850,000
4 Beds 5 Baths
Welcome to luxurious waterfront living in the highly sought after Reservoir community in Colts Neck. Over 4,000 sq ft, this totally renovated raised Ranch offers unparalleled water views from almost every room creating a serene and picturesque backdrop. Step inside to discover a meticulously designed interior ideal for today's lifestyle. The main level features an open concept layout making entertaining a breeze. Relax and unwind in the living room, where a stone fireplace extends to the soaring vaulted ceiling adorned with rustic wood beams creating an inviting atmosphere. Banquet sized dining area can accommodate a large gathering. The kitchen is a chef's dream, complete with upgraded SS appliance package, coffered ceilings, expansive center island with honed & leathered granite countertops. The primary suite, conveniently located on the first floor, offers a private sanctuary with an ensuite bathroom plus two walk in closets. Multiple sliders provide access to the upper deck surrounded by nature's beauty. Upstairs loft area offers a quiet space to work or study and plenty of storage. Venture to the lower level where you'll find a spacious family room featuring a full wet bar, gas fireplace and additional recreation space for creating new memories. Sliding doors open to back patio for seamless indoor-outdoor entertaining offering breathtaking water views. Two lower level bedrooms share a Jack 'n Jill bathroom while the third bedroom boasts a princess suite providing comfort and privacy for all. Experience waterfront living at its finest in this exquisite Colts Neck retreat where luxury meets tranquility. Don't miss the opportunity to make this your dream home!

37 Beaver Dam Road, Colts Neck

Listing courtesy of Heritage House Sotheby's International Realty. Contact:

Selling Office: Coldwell Banker Realty.

$2,000,000
5 Beds 4 Baths
1.6ac on the sought-after Swimming River Reservoir. This 4,500sf 4BR (w/ 5th BR apt over garage) offers the rare waterfront lifestyle in horse country. Enter property via circular drive & you're drawn to the water. Inside, vaulted ceiling heights & custom moulding provide a Colonial floorplan w/ Tudor details. Kitchen & FamilyRoom views extend beyond the stone patio, outdoor kitchen & terrace to the gleaming River beyond. Dorbrook Park across the River means no neighbors opposite you. Upstairs includes a Princess Suite w/ new bathroom, 2 generous-sized Guest BRs w/ Guest bathroom, & a 1,000sf Master Suite w/ remodeled bathroom, sitting room & tons of closet space. A door connects to the Guest Apt w/ rear balcony overlooking the River. 1.6ac on the sought-after Swimming River Reservoir. This 4,500sf 4BR (w/ 5th BR apt over garage) offers the rare waterfront lifestyle in horse country. Enter the property via circular drive & feel yourself being drawn to the water. Inside, vaulted ceiling heights and custom moulding provide a Colonial floorplan w/ Tudor details. Kitchen & Family Room views extend beyond the stone patio, outdoor kitchen & terrace to the gleaming River beyond. Dorbrook Park across the River means no neighbors staring opposite you. Upstairs includes a Princess Suite w/ new bathroom, 2 generous-sized Guest BRs w/ Guest bathroom, & a 1,000sf Master Suite w/ remodeled bathroom, sitting room and tons of closet space. A door connects to the Guest Apt w/ rear balcony overlooking the River. Full basement w/ daylight access to the 3-car garage.

27 Beaver Dam Road, Colts Neck

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Realty Central Monmouth. Contact:

Selling Office: Robert DeFalco Realty Inc..

$1,780,000
6 Beds 6 Baths
Welcome to an extraordinary waterfront estate situated on prestigious Rivers Edge Drive, overlooking the pristine waters of the Swimming River Reservoir. This exceptional property showcases 6 bedrooms and 5 and a half bathrooms, offering appx 7,000 sq ft luxurious living space including basement. Gourmet kitchen with open floor plan and newer Subzero appliances. Maplewood cabinets and granite countertops. 10ft Ceilings on the 1st floor with a Princess Suite. Reservoir views from the expansive windows throughout the residence. Indulge in the opulent amenities, including a sports court/pickleball. Can easily replace with a pool if desired. Expansive Master Bedroom with Dressing Rm & 5 closets, w/marble Master Bath w/ tub & shower. Easy commute to NYC & close to shopping & NJ Shore. Welcome to Rivers Edge Drive, a breathtaking haven nestled on the majestic shores of the Swimming River Reservoir in Colts Neck. This 1.26-acre lot presents a truly unparalleled lifestyle opportunity, with the property being the only available waterfront developed lot on the Swimming River Reservoir in Colts Neck. The magnificence of this 6 bedroom, 5.5 bathroom home is announced by the awe-inspiring 25ft entryway, adorned with intricate decorative molding and a stunning chandelier. As you step onto the gleaming marble flooring and take in the large archways, shadow boxes, and oak wood railing, it becomes evident that every element in this house has been meticulously designed and crafted. The heart of the home is the expansive gourmet kitchen, fitted with top-of-the-line Viking appliances, maple wood custom cabinets, and a spacious custom pantry. The kitchen also features a double granite island countertop with a 6 burner gas stove with downdraft venting to ensure high-performance cooking. Double wall ovens, a large Sub Zero refrigerator/freezer, two additional refrigerators for wine and drinks, and a double sink that overlooks the tranquil views of the yard and reservoir. The beautiful blend of granite countertops, tumbled marble backsplash with a unique rooster design tile, and custom maple wood cabinets speak volumes about the kitchen's attention to detail. An open floor plan connects this space to a large dining room , adorned with a bay window, and custom seating making it perfect for entertaining. A large custom pantry and a wine buffet completes the features, providing plenty of space for all your storage needs. Your culinary aspirations will find their home in the impressive kitchen. The ceiling beams add an element of rustic charm while the built-in cabinets in the Butler Pantry area enhance functionality. Dinner parties will be a delight with such a spectacular setting. The first floor is characterized by 10ft ceilings throughout, a large formal living room, a dedicated office space, and a sunroom. This level also features a family room/den area off the kitchen, perfect for watching TV with the family. The Guest bedroom, with an updated en-suite bathroom completes the floor. Exquisite hardwood flooring adds an element of warmth and sophistication throughout. Adjacent to the large formal Living room, an airy office/library lined with custom built-in wall cabinets presents the perfect setting for productivity or leisurely reading. French doors open to a sunroom that exudes tranquility. Overlooking the mature landscaping and expansive yard, this sun-drenched space promises serenity amid the hustle and bustle of daily life. A set of elegant stairs upon entry leads to the second floor, marked by 9ft ceilings and the resplendent owners suite. On the second floor, the owner's suite stands as the crown jewel, boasting a high vaulted ceiling, decorative molding, oak floors, and four large closets with a dressing room. The en-suite bathroom serves as a personal spa, featuring marble finishes, double sinks, a large walk-in shower, and a soaking tub with jets. On each side of the owner's suite are two sets of two bedrooms (4 additional bedrooms) grace either side of the master suite, each pair sharing Jack-and-Jill bathrooms fitted with double sinks and ceramic tile. Completing the second floor is a playroom area, which can also function as a den or recreation room. The beautifully finished basement is a world in itself, with its 8 ft ceilings and an additional 1200-1500 sq ft of versatile, heated living space. This area can comfortably house a media room or gym, and currently boasts a pool table area, a large living area with a wrap-around couch that provides a venue for recreation and entertainment, and ceramic tile flooring in its own,discrete full bathroom.. Even with all these amenities, the basement still offers ample storage space, with additional closets and utility areas. Embrace the joys of outdoor living on the sprawling Brazilian "Ipe" deck. Constructed from exotic wood that is three times harder than white oak, the deck is as durable as it is beautiful. With retractable awnings installed for easy creation to shaded areas, you can enjoy this outdoor living space in all weather conditions. The deck leads down to a 30x60ft sports court, ideal for roller hockey or basketball. Beyond the sports court, a gate opens to the reservoir, bringing the beauty of the Swimming River Reservoir to your backyard. Whether you enjoy boating, swimming, or simply observing the tranquil water, this home offers unparalleled access to waterfront activities. The home's functional features include a 3-car garage, a 75 gallon hot water heater, two electrical panels, and a sprinkler system. The garage also provides direct access to the basement, enhancing convenience. In essence, this is not merely a home, but a lifestyle. The unique combination of opulence, comfort, and natural beauty on offer at River's Edge Drive is unmatched. Here, the luxury of a finely appointed home blends seamlessly with the tranquility of waterfront living, making every day a resort-like experience. Whether you're enjoying the exquisite interiors or exploring the spectacular outdoor amenities, living here is truly an experience of a lifetime. Experience the Colts Neck lifestyle at its best with this splendidly appointed residence. Its fusion of grand scale living, luxurious finishes, and an idyllic location make it a masterpiece of residential architecture. Whether you're lounging on your deck, shooting hoops on your private court, roller skating, or taking a peaceful stroll by the reservoir, this estate presents a life of unending enjoyment and relaxation. All room sizes approximate. Township said a pool can be put in place of sports court with proper submissions following guidelines, setbacks, and lot coverage. PICKLEBALL CAN BE PLAYED ON THE SPORTS COURT!

18 Rivers Edge Drive, Colts Neck

Listing courtesy of Robert DeFalco Realty Inc.. Contact:

Selling Office: Keller Williams Realty West Monmouth.

Start Your Search

Colts Neck Waterfront Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for waterfront properties available in Colts Neck and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire. 

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood! 

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Contact us today to find out how we can be of assistance to you!