Quick Colts Neck NJ MLS Search

Browse All Colts Neck NJ Between $3 Million - $4 Million Properties for Sale

$3,695,000
4 Beds 5 Baths
There is only one property in Colts Neck that offers direct, cleared waterfront access to the Swimming River Reservoir; and this is it. 57 Beaver Dam Road is not simply a home; it is a once-in-a-generation estate where meticulous renovation, uncompromising craftsmanship, and an outdoor sanctuary unlike anything else on the market converge on 1.27 breathtaking acres with nearly 350 feet of water frontage. This is waterfront living, redefined. Reimagined and expertly expanded in 2019-2020, this 4-bedroom, 4-full and 1-half-bath Colonial boasts a total of nearly 6,000 square feet of living space, of extraordinary craftsmanship seen in every corner. A dramatic double-height foyer welcomes you into a home where no detail was left unconsidered. The main level unfolds with effortless elegance: two distinct living spaces, a private office, a first-floor primary suite, and a stunning kitchen renovation completed in 2025, fully appointed for the most discerning of chefs and entertainers. Multiple points of access lead you directly to the resplendent backyard and sweeping, unobstructed views of the Swimming River Reservoir. A recessed bar offers panoramic vistas of the property, designed for effortless entertaining at any scale. Descend to the full basement, where a fully enclosed, temperature-controlled wine room awaits, capable of housing hundreds of bottles for the true connoisseur. A full bath, generous space for a home gym or private retreat, and direct access to the garage complete this level. Upstairs, two generously proportioned bedrooms share a beautifully appointed full bath, while a secondary suite offers its own private ensuite. Words scarcely do justice to this outdoor masterpiece, crafted by the renowned Millennium Stoneworks. Two tiers of decking set the stage for an entertainer's paradise, anchored by multiple fire pits, integrated outdoor lighting, and surround sound spread throughout the grounds. The outdoor kitchen is nothing short of world-class, equipped with a teppanyaki grill, Chicago Brick Oven, Alfresco grill and burners, refrigeration, ice storage, and so much more all crowned in leathered granite countertops beneath a motorized pergola built for effortless, all-season enjoyment. The pool deck and entertaining area are finished in oversized, imported Italian porcelain tile, guiding you past yet another fire pit overlooking the property to a custom cabana featuring an 8 person+ Caldera spa, a 6ft wide Montego gas fireplace, misting fans, Bromic heaters, integrated speakers, and more! The cabana doubles as a striking diving platform into the deep end of the heated pool, with a depth of ~10 feet. Set on 1.27 pristine acres with nearly 350 feet of combined water frontage; the only property of its kind offering cleared, direct, and walk-in access to the Swimming River Reservoir. 57 Beaver Dam Road is a genuinely irreplaceable offering. Just minutes from downtown Lincroft, Lifetime Fitness, and the area's finest shopping and dining, this estate delivers the rare combination of total privacy, natural beauty, and everyday convenience. For the buyer who demands nothing less than extraordinary, 57 Beaver Dam Road isn't just a home, it's a legacy.

57 Beaver Dam Road, Colts Neck

Listing courtesy of Serhant New Jersey LLC. Contact:

$3,400,000
5 Beds 7 Baths
For the most discerning buyer, this custom-built estate is a true showpiece. Every detail has been thoughtfully curated--from the striking architectural design to the finest materials and craftsmanship throughout The home features rich hardwood floors, imported stone, granite countertops, intricate moldings, radiant heat, arched doorways, and three fireplaces. Additional highlights include a wine cellar, home theater, sauna, and a beautifully appointed pool house. A grand entrance begins with stunning double mahogany doors, leading into a warm and inviting interior. The gourmet eat-in kitchen is a chef's dream, complete with stainless steel appliances, a 6-burner Thermador stove, and a farmhouse sink. The family room, anchored by a wood-burning fireplace and custom built-ins, offers the perfect space to unwind, while the elegant study with a coffered mahogany ceiling makes working from home both comfortable and refined. Each bedroom is spacious and filled with natural light, featuring walk-in closets and unique design elements--including one with a hand-blown Murano glass chandelier, domed ceiling, and private balcony. The primary suite is a private retreat, offering a sitting area with a fireplace and a versatile loft ideal for a nursery or reading space. The spa-like bath showcases an onyx steam shower, marble floors, dual vanities, custom cabinetry, and a whirlpool tub. The finished basement is designed for entertaining, featuring a home theater, wet bar, wine cellar, sauna, and fitness room. Outdoors, the lifestyle continues with a full-scale entertaining area--complete with a fireplace, pizza oven, bluestone patio, and a sparkling in-ground saltwater pool. A guest/pool house with its own bedroom, bathroom, and kitchen completes this exceptional offering. A true home for the connoisseur of fine living.

8 Country Club Lane, Colts Neck

Listing courtesy of Heritage House Sotheby's International Realty. Contact:

Selling Office: O'Brien Realty, LLC.

$3,400,000
5 Beds 6 Baths
Over 8,000 sq ft of living space including lower level. Set on 2.56 acres of private, picturesque grounds, this exceptional residence is fully wrapped in elegant thin-stone on all sides, offering timeless appeal and an elevated blend of space, sophistication, and versatility in a serene neighborhood that abuts a prestigious country club. A three-car garage and impressive curb appeal set the tone for what awaits inside. Rich hardwood floors flow throughout, leading to a beautifully updated chef's kitchen featuring a dramatic waterfall island that opens seamlessly to the main living areas--perfectly designed for both refined entertaining and everyday living. A dedicated home office and first-floor laundry add effortless convenience, while a thoughtfully designed first-floor in-law suite offers its own full kitchen and living room creating a private, fully equipped second living space ideal for extended family or guests. The expansive primary suite is a true retreat, showcasing soaring, beamed ceilings that enhance the light-filled ambiance. The stunning, fully finished lower level is an entertainer's dream, featuring a large bar, wet bar setup, and dedicated exercise area--offering endless possibilities for recreation and leisure. With generously scaled rooms and a tranquil, park-like setting, this is a rare opportunity to own a truly distinguished home.

3 Bretwood Drive N, Colts Neck

Listing courtesy of Heritage House Sotheby's International Realty. Contact:

Selling Office: RE/MAX Central.

$3,799,000
6 Beds 7 Baths
Welcome to this extraordinary 10,000 sq. ft estate set within the prestigious Due Process Estates of Colts Neck, where timeless grandeur meets refined modern luxury. From the moment you enter, you are greeted by soaring 30-foot ceilings, a dramatic double staircase, and gleaming marble floors that set the tone for this impeccably designed residence.Thoughtfully designed for both upscale entertaining and everyday luxury, the home offers an impressive collection of refined living and gathering spaces, perfectly suited for hosting everything from intimate evenings to large-scale events.At the heart of the home is a fully renovated chef's kitchen, showcasing custom imported Italian cabinetry, designer tilework, expansive preparation areas, and abundant natural light. At the heart of the home is a fully renovated chef's kitchen, showcasing custom imported Italian cabinetry, Versace tilework, expansive preparation areas, and abundant natural light. Designed with both form and function in mind, this space delivers a seamless culinary and entertaining experience. This home features seven spacious bedrooms, including a lavish primary suite complete with bespoke custom closets and a spa-inspired bath appointed with elevated, designer finishes. Additional living quarters provide flexibility for guests or extended living arrangements, all thoughtfully integrated into the home's refined layout. The second level is enhanced by rich Brazilian flooring, intricate architectural ceiling designs, and detailed custom millwork, adding warmth and character throughout. Private outdoor access from the upper level offers serene views overlooking the expansive grounds. A fully finished lower level provides approximately 5,000 sq ft of additional space, offering endless possibilities for a private theater, wine cellar, fitness center, or customized entertainment retreat. Outdoors, a resort-style setting awaits with a custom gunite saltwater pool surrounded by an expansive slate patio and dedicated entertaining areas. The grounds offer a rare combination of privacy and open space, ideal for hosting or relaxing in a tranquil environment. Notable upgrades include a newer roof, fully remodeled kitchen and bathrooms with high-end designer finishes, custom closet systems, new flooring throughout the main level, an updated HVAC system, and fully upgraded UV/LED lighting throughout the interior and exterior. A state-of-the-art security system enhances both comfort and peace of mind. Ideally located near major highways, premier schools, parks, beaches, and offering convenient access to New York City, this exceptional residence presents a rare opportunity to experience luxury living at its finest.

4 Squan Song Lane, Colts Neck

Listing courtesy of Jason Mitchell Real Estate New Jersey. Contact:

$3,150,000
5 Beds 8 Baths
Discriminating buyers will be impressed with this luxurious 5 bed, 7.5 bath custom Colonial located in the prestigious Due Process West neighborhood & situated on over 3.3 acres of pure privacy & beauty. Captivating elegance & inspiring design is what you will first notice as you pass through the gates, down a long circular Belgium block paver driveway that is surrounded by meticulously maintained, mature landscaping. Careful selection & quality-crafted appointments can be seen throughout the home. Gorgeous double door entrance welcomes you in, featuring a grand 2-story foyer with curved stairway. Distinctive features include, 7 fireplaces, coffered ceilings in both kitchen & Great Room, built-ins throughout, 3 wet bars, architectural moldings & 9 ft ceilings on 1st & 2nd floors, and the list goes on. For the entertainer in you, the 1st level boasts of a bright, open floor plan, offering the ultimate designer eat-in kitchen, spectacular formal 2-story living room, elegant dining room enhanced with wainscoting, beautiful Great Room, lovely octagon sunroom, home office, stately den & large laundry room. As you retreat to the 2nd level you will be impressed with the graceful & generous sized 5 bedrooms & 5 baths. Magnificent primary bedroom enclave offers a tray ceiling, large walk-in closet & huge sitting area. Enjoy morning coffee & evening tea on the expansive balcony while soaking in the peace & tranquility of your home. Primary bath rivals any 5-star hotel with whirlpool tub, separate shower, custom tile & double sinks. Also located on 2nd level is a regal library with dome ceiling & bonus room, only limited by one's own imagination. Full finished basement is a true gem complete with gym, theater room & multiple entertainment areas. Resort-like backyard features a spectacular expansive covered patio, built-in BBQ & glistening Gunite pool & spa. Living in Colts Neck offers proximity to beautiful beaches, golf courses, horse farms, parks & NYC transportation.

2 Squan Song Lane, Colts Neck

Listing courtesy of Heritage House Sotheby's International Realty. Contact:

Selling Office: NON MEMBER.

$3,750,000
5 Beds 7 Baths
NEW CONSTRUCTION. Brand-new home is nearing completion & can be finished by mid-late Spring. Magnificent 6,000+ sq ft. Modern Farmhouse nestled on 3 acres in addition to adjoining 50 beautiful farmland assessed acreage. Home boasts 5/6 BRs, 6.5 baths, primary BR suites on 1st & 2nd flr, bonus game rm, massive kitchen w/ vaulted ceilings, lrg walk-in pantry, oversized EIK adjacent to palatial 2 story family rm w/ double-sided fireplace, huge laundry rm with an optional 2nd flr laundry, gigantic walkout basement w/rough plumbing for full bath, designated gym area & direct garage access. Construction details; Hardi Board Siding, Azek trim, Marvin Windows & doors, Superior Walls Basement Foundation, Spray foam insulation, 300 amp Electric service, 9' Garage drs, home prepped for Generac generator, fireplaces prepped for Natural stone veneer & much more. If you can dream it..this house has it! Nestled amongst several other multi-million-dollar estates, this property has so much to offer. Rolling farmland, small stream, bountiful wildlife, and beautiful wooded property lines offer solitude and privacy. There are endless opportunities for outdoor activities including, but not limited to equestrian life, farming, cattle, chickens, bees, gardening, nursery/ landscape, hunting, or simply keeping it green and practicing your golf swing. A newly renovated 4,800 sq. foot barn can be used for horses, car collections, private parties, equipment storage or crafting.

8 Hillcrest Drive, Colts Neck

Listing courtesy of Heritage House Sotheby's International Realty. Contact:

Selling Office: Prominent Properties Sotheby's.

Start Your Search

Between $3 Million - $4 Million Colts Neck Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for between $3 million - $4 million properties available in Colts Neck and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire. 

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood! 

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Contact us today to find out how we can be of assistance to you!